What have I done? Only time will tell. I may have just ruined the appearance of my guitar, then again it may come out okay. I've added a few more photos of this step, just to give a better idea of what I did.
I started out by super gluing the pearl in place and then used a craft knife to trace around the outside, leaving me with an outline.
It was during this process that I dropped the inlay on the ground and it shattered into two.... and my blood pressure started to climb.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4ad86/4ad86c53eb23d30072938cf2b8e6a73e6388ce82" alt=""
Then it all went totally pair shaped. The edges of the pearl were not square and although I spent ages, taking my time, working the edges out, I still managed to stuff it up, taking away wood in the wrong places.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4a575/4a575c1171009ff921fb516efaba47b7e8406ca1" alt=""
Needless to say, my blood was beginning to boil.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/37ca1/37ca18d5860df1d406c01de71d540f79ef80889a" alt=""
Not being able to take a backwards step, I was left with only one option. I got the sandpaper out and rubbed down scraps left over from the overlay and then mixed some clear expoxy and tinted it with the dust.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/48f6d/48f6d0cffbfc8667c2f7e58b26d888da8904a3da" alt=""
The plan is that when I rub it back tomorrow, it'll be perfect and you'll never be able to notice that the job was completed by a mere amateur.
Ten minutes after the last photo I thought to myself, "I should have glued that down, I hope the expoxy holds it in place"
Time taken : 2.5 hours
Tools used : craft knife, super glue, epoxy, sandpaper
AU$'s spent : Nil